BREAKING
Business

REIT or InvIT? Yield is not the whole story for investors

The usual comparison investors make to distinguish between two investment avenues are based on their performance or returns. While returns are an important barometer, that doesn’t alone provide us the correct judgement and most critically would that investment suit the investors’ requirements. So, when the topic of REITs (Real Estate Investment Trust) and InvITs (Investment Trust) is discussed, investors end up checking on their yields to decide on the investment. But, how accurate is that comparison?

Both these investment avenues are SEBI (Securities Exchange Board of India) regulated and listed trusts that distribute at least 90% of their net distributable cash flows. However, they differ fundamentally in underlying assets, cash flow sources, and risk profiles. A crucial recent regulatory change also has reshaped how mutual funds (MF) can invest in them where REITs are classified as equity while InvITs remain as hybrid.

Earlier (to 1st Jan ’26) both shared a combined investment ceiling for MF but now debt funds can no longer make fresh investments in REITs. This change allows equity-oriented MFs to invest in REITs without specific mention in their offer documents, potentially broadening the investor base for REITs.

On average, an InvIT yield ranges from 9-13% while that of REITs about 6-7%. This makes the former more attractive but deciding your investment choice based on this alone could hurt. First let’s understand how these operate. A REIT invests in income-generating property like commercial real estate (offices/malls) and earns rental income from them. On the other hand, an InvIT invests in infrastructure assets like roads, powerlines and pipelines, etc. and holds the right to collect tolls or user charges over these assets for a fixed period.

Usually, these periods are finite like that of 15 or 20 years. The income received is stable but the right to collect income from that asset ends after the contractual period. The trust either must acquire newer assets or should hold other assets to not wind down. Meanwhile, a REIT, can continue to earn rent for as long as it owns the property. The former is a contractual payout and the latter is an equity or ownership of an asset. That’s the reason for the distinction of tax treatment or categorization.

The InvIT incomes are largely predefined with limited room for growth or capital appreciation while a REIT may offer lower yields but could remain offering for longer periods with chances of appreciation in rental incomes and underlying property value. And investors should be mindful of the fact that not all the InvIT distribution is income earned during that period. Some distributions may simply be unutilized capital the trust raised and is returning to the investors. This is return of capital and not income. So, every distribution doesn’t mean high income from the asset.

Moreover, while both the products are less immune to macroeconomic conditions, the rental and lease income for REITs are usually stable due to long-term leases with corporate tenants. However, InvIT could experience much variable cashflows due to traffic exposure risk, regulatory changes, and project-specific factors. Also, the complex nature of the assets in InvIT and their large trading lots offer lesser liquidity to the investors, particularly during distress. The regulatory leverage limit is up to 49% of asset value for REITs and up to 70% of asset value for InvITs.

And investors shouldn’t alone consider the post-tax returns as a parameter to consider these investments. Their role in the portfolio should be aligned to the investors’ needs and nature of the investment.

Though, the nomenclature like rental income, capital distribution, etc. sound similar to fixed income they should not be mistaken for fixed deposits as their distributions are not guaranteed and their unit prices could fall.

Retail investors could explore these through MF route i.e., through multi-asset and other hybrid structures where these instruments have exposure. So, a higher current payout by InvIT is not necessarily a superior product over a REIT at a lower current yield as the latter could have a longer runway and potential for growth in both rentals and capital appreciation. For investors wanting relatively stable income, higher liquidity and greater potential for appreciation without directly owning the properties could consider REITs while relatively volatile yet higher distribution yields could look for InvITs.

The choice hence depends on the individual investor’s risk appetite, income needs and existing portfolio composition. The author is a partner with “Wealocity Analytics”, a SEBI registered Research Analyst and could be reached at info@wealocityanalytics.com